FLIP/GIFT
Log InSign Up
All platform ratings

MyGiftCardSupply Review 2026: Is It Legit? Ratings, Complaints & Safer Alternatives

B
MarketplaceTrustpilot: 3.9 (6,842 reviews) · checked October 2026FlipGift users: —Scorecard updated October 15, 2026

A long-running digital gift card retailer (US cards for international buyers) with the largest review base in this index: 3.9 across ~6,800 reviews — 79% five-star, with a persistent 11% one-star tail of failed codes and verification blocks.

Safety scorecard

Code custody — Does your code stay safe until you receive value?
Retail model: you buy digital codes, you never surrender one. There is no consumer sell-side.
Drain liability — If the balance disappears mid-deal, are you protected?
Dead-code reports exist with mixed outcomes — some buyers describe refunds after contacting support, others report no refund for a code that would not redeem.
Balance verification — Is the balance checked right before the exchange?
Codes are sourced and delivered digitally; failures surface at redemption, and resolution then depends on support.
Dispute process — Is there real, time-bound recourse?
Email support responds in most accounts, but reviewers report multi-day silences on redemption problems.
Payment reliability — Do payouts arrive as promised?
Advertised delivery is fast (reviewers cite ~30 minutes); delays and out-of-stock items discovered after payment are recurring complaints.
Fee transparency — Do you know the exact cut upfront?
The price per card is shown upfront.

How MyGiftCardSupply works

MyGiftCardSupply sells digital gift card codes — primarily US-region cards (iTunes, Google Play, Amazon and similar) to international customers who need a US code. Payment first, code by email after, typically within the hour. The Trustpilot profile has been claimed by the company since 2015 and carries a paid subscription.

At ~6,842 reviews (checked October 2026) the sample is the deepest in this index: 79% five-star describing exactly what the service advertises, and an 11% one-star tail with three recurring themes — codes that fail to redeem (with refund outcomes varying by case), KYC checks that block paid orders, and support that takes days on redemption disputes.

As with any code retailer, your money moves first; the code and its validity arrive second.

What reviewers report

Themes paraphrased from public Trustpilot reviews, checked October 2026.

Codes that fail to redeem
The main negative theme: a purchased code will not redeem, and the refund outcome varies — some resolved by support, some reviewers report no refund.
Verification blocks after payment
Reviewers report completing KYC and still having orders stopped, including established repeat customers.
Slow support on disputes
Several days without a response is a recurring report when a redemption problem is raised.

FlipGift user reviews

No user reviews yet — used MyGiftCardSupply? Your experience helps others.

Log in to leave a review. Reviews are moderated and require an account to prevent astroturfing.

Frequently asked questions

Is MyGiftCardSupply legit?

Yes — it is a real retailer operating since the mid-2010s, rated 3.9 on Trustpilot across roughly 6,800 reviews (checked October 2026). 81% of reviewers rate it five stars. The risk profile is buyer-side: about one review in ten reports a code that failed to redeem, an order blocked by verification, or slow support on a dispute.

Does MyGiftCardSupply buy gift cards?

No — it only sells digital codes. If you are trying to sell or swap an unwanted card, this is not the platform for that.

Compare with other platforms

Compare FlipGift with other ways to sell

Or see every site compared · safety ratings of every site

Prefer not to hand over your code and hope?

FlipGift removes the step where most platforms put you at risk: in an escrow deal the seller keeps their card and redeems it personally, so no card code ever changes hands. We held ourselves to that standard too — we retired our own swap product on July 23, 2026, because any trade where the code changes hands can't be made fully safe.