FLIP/GIFT
Log InSign Up

Sell Your American Eagle Gift Card for Cash

Updated September 23, 2026 · Reviewed by Kirill Novikov, FlipGift founder

Diagram of a FlipGift escrow deal: buyer pays into escrow, seller orders with their gift card, the item ships with proof, then the money is released

Sell your American Eagle gift card for cash without handing anyone the number or PIN. You use the card to pay for a buyer's American Eagle order, their money waits in escrow, and it's released to you when the order arrives — typically 72–88% of face value, against the 60–85% buy-back sites pay after taking the code.

Why American Eagle gift cards go unused

AE cards are teen-gift defaults — tastes move to the next brand before the balance does.

How to sell your American Eagle card the safe way

  1. List your American Eagle card — brand and balance only, never the code.
  2. A buyer who wants jeans from American Eagle pays for their order into escrow.
  3. You place their order with your card and upload the confirmation and tracking.
  4. When they confirm delivery, escrow pays you.

How the fee, escrow and disputes work: how escrow works · selling without sharing the code.

Ready to cash out your American Eagle card? List your American Eagle card →

American Eagle at a glance

Sellers ready nowNone today — post a request and the next American Eagle seller sees it
CategoryApparel shoes
Free shipping at$75+ on American Eagle.com
Flat shipping below that$8
In the catalogueYes — requests accepted

Live from the FlipGift order book.

Before you list: check your American Eagle balance

American Eagle lets you check the balance online, on the issuer’s balance page, and you will need the PIN from the back of the card.

  1. Open the American Eagle balance link.
  2. Enter the card number.
  3. Enter the PIN and submit to see the remaining value.

Official American Eagle balance checker · Full American Eagle balance guide

What a $100 American Eagle card pays on FlipGift

Where you sellYou keep
FlipGift Escrow
typical 10–20% discount, after the 2.5% seller fee — no live offer on this store right now
$78–$88

Per $100 of face value, to your FlipGift balance after the 2.5% seller fee.

Rules of the American Eagle gift card

Works on the websiteYes
Works in storeYes
ExpiresNever
FeesNone
Digital (e-gift) card offeredYes
Gift cards per online order3
Not valid forAEO credit card payments; other gift cards; cash except as required by law

AEO Inc. gift card is shared across American Eagle Outfitters, Aerie, Tailgate, and Don't Ask Why stores/sites in US and Canada. Up to 3 gift cards redeemable per online order.

Source: American Eagle gift card terms, checked 2026-09-02

Official source: American Eagle gift card page

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to share my American Eagle card number or PIN to sell it?

No. You keep the card and use it to pay for a buyer's American Eagle order yourself — the number and PIN are never typed into any site or handed to anyone.

How much will I get for my American Eagle gift card?

Typically 72–88% of face value: you set the discount, the buyer pays that price into escrow, and you keep it minus a 2.5% seller fee and the 2% withdrawal fee. Buy-back sites usually pay 60–85% and take the code first.

How fast do I get paid for my American Eagle card?

When the buyer confirms their American Eagle order arrived — or automatically about 16 days after it ships if they never respond. You can then withdraw as crypto or a digital prepaid Visa card.

More gift cards you can sell this way

No open orders at American Eagle this minute

The newest American Eagle listing gets the next order.

List a American Eagle card
Buyers are waiting at these stores right now:
Sell your card for cash — no code shared